A dispute over Tether's financial strength has divided crypto observers after BitMEX co-founder Arthur Hayes warned that the stablecoin issuer's bet on Bitcoin and gold could backfire. A former Citi bank analyst countered that public attestations miss tens of billions in additional equity. The disagreement centers on how much buffer the company holds against market shocks.
What Happened: Former Analyst Challenges Hayes Assessment
Hayes said late last month that a roughly 30% drop in Tether's BTC and gold holdings could eliminate the company's equity and leave USDT exposed.
He described the firm's asset allocation as an early bet that Federal Reserve rate cuts will reduce interest income, prompting a shift toward assets that might rise as the cost of money falls.
A former Citi research analyst who uses the name Joseph spent hundreds of hours reviewing filings and estimates Tether's total equity sits between $50 billion and $100 billion.
He said public attestations show only the assets backing outstanding USDT and exclude the full corporate balance sheet.
Joseph calculated that Tether holds about $120 billion in U.S. Treasuries earning roughly 4%, which could produce about $10 billion in annual net income. He also cited equity stakes, mining operations and additional Bitcoin holdings that do not appear in reserve snapshots.
Paolo Ardoino, Tether's chief executive, has publicly stated the firm maintains roughly $30 billion in group equity as a buffer against market swings. Hayes argued that volatile assets move fast and that marked declines would reduce reserve values, potentially creating liquidity trouble even if long-term equity remains large.
Also Read: Bitcoin Liquidation Dominance Reaches Three-Year High Of 32% As Leveraged Bulls Absorb Losses
Why It Matters: Disclosure Gap Fuels Market Uncertainty
The debate exposes a transparency problem that has followed Tether for years. Attestations focus on the supply of USDT and may not reveal how quickly the company could mobilize other assets during a crisis. If Tether's broader holdings can be deployed fast in a stress event, the firm may weather sharp price swings. If those assets remain siloed or illiquid, short-term volatility could strain redemptions despite a healthy balance sheet.
Investors remain uneasy because the core numbers are large but incomplete.
The $120 billion in Treasuries, the $30 billion equity figure cited by management and Joseph's $50 billion to $100 billion estimate all suggest substantial capital. Yet without full disclosure of how those assets interconnect or how quickly they can be accessed, the market cannot confirm whether Tether's cushion matches the scale of its liabilities.
Hayes framed the allocation shift as a macro hedge against expected rate cuts, but that strategy carries risk if Bitcoin and gold prices tumble in tandem. The clash between his warning and Joseph's rebuttal highlights competing views on whether Tether's reserve structure is resilient or fragile under stress.
Read Next: Technical Analysis Points To $106,450 Bitcoin Target Despite Bearish Trend